CYBILS F/SF: And Now, The Post-Mortem…

So, yeah. The Cybils, 2012, YA Fantasy/Sci Fi.
205, at final count, in our category. 99.7% books read by one person, 98.6% of the books were read by two people, .03% unread (the discrepancy is because some books were difficult to get – some individual self-pubbed authors and smaller presses just didn’t have the wherewithal to send copies or give us digital access), and 199 books were read by me.

Around the end of last month, I be tard, which is why you’re getting your post mortem just over a week after all the confetti was thrown. Lord. Have. Mercy. What a year.

The 2013 Cybils wasn’t easy for YA F/SF. It wasn’t so much the number of books – for the first time in five years, it was easier for me to access them than not; I have three counties library systems from which to choose, and was willing and able to poach my sisters’ library cards – but it was the deliberations. Sheila often calls it the Survival of the Book Fittest. Either you read a book and the plot sticks with you, or it …goes by the wayside as a readalike or just another piece of plot in an endless mountain of story. There were simply Too. Many. Good. Books. Should I shortlist this silly, lightweight novel which immediately caught my eye? Should I downgrade silly when something heavier-hitting came my way? Should I add this one, despite the fact that the hero annoys me a bit, because we need more books guys would enjoy? These are the types of things that go round and round and round in the secondary phase of narrowing down our lists. Sure – the knee-jerk, uncritical pleasure we have in cracking each book is there, and some people have an initial shortlist and have sixteen books on it — and then they agonize as they pare it down. My style tends toward more critical reading early on, and this year, the paring started on day one, and went on and on and on.

It didn’t make deliberations any easier when adding others to the mix. For the first time since I’ve been on a Cybils panel — since the very beginning; a year on YA Fiction and five on YA F/SF – the judges met and were unable to come to a consensus in a single three hour session. We had to go away and come back, and after some heated exchanges and outbursts some returned owing to others sincere apologies And some sincerity is still owing, but I will belt up and let that go. Eventually. Deliberations took, all told, nine hours. All flippin’ day. (Imagine if I’d still been in Scotland, having to get up at 3 a.m. for deliberations…!)

We came up with a list I mostly like. There is never 100% LOVE from anyone for any list; there are a couple of books on the list which are iffy for me — and there are a couple of books on the list which are clearly hot-button books for others. For the most part, though, it is a good, sturdy list of worthy books. However! I still wish we’d had room for…

GRAVE MERCY, by Robin LaFevers. Now, y’all know I LOVED this book. LOVED IT. It is not every day when you start the day just thinking you’ll read a chapter or two of a book, and then the day gets eaten up with you and your book, and by evening, you pretty much have to sit down and write a thank-you note to the author because she’d helped you pleasurably waste an entire day. (This may not happen to you a lot, but I always try and let myself be happy when it happens to me. Life is short. Truly great books are rare.)

Robin wrote up one of my favorite adult-style tales for young adults, about a Wronged Woman who morphs into a Castaway, and then by the turn of the Wheel and on a whim of the Fates, she becomes A Warrior Woman. So many tropes, so freshly scrubbed up and nicely presented! It was so satisfying – beginning, middle, end, DONE. No dangling bits of this fair assassin’s tale, nope. She was all tied up in a pretty bow, and yet, the worldbuilding leaves room for more stories. I cannot wait for the next, and it was really disappointing to be unable to include this book in our finalist list. I was fair gutted. But, what to do, what to do?! There were just so many great books we couldn’t include, like…

LOSERS IN SPACE, by John Barnes. I was SO SURE this book would be a shoo-in for the list; I was certain. But my shortlisting it on my personal list was met with a few folk scrambling and complaining that they couldn’t find it. Like so many others this time around, this book suffered from lack of easy access and time issues. Many people weren’t able to make it past the first few chapters of set-up, and if you don’t persevere with this one, it’s easy to say, “WHAT? She’s SO annoying!” I agree that the book starts carefully, with the character equivalent of stepping gingerly on sidewalks and avoiding cracks, but by a third of the way through, the narrative pelts along, running full out, cracks be darned. The narrative starts the way it does for a reason, I promise you: KEEP READING past the first quiet – and possibly annoyingly voiced – beginnings.

A lot of people had the same reaction to M.T. Anderson’s FEED. Why they wondered, do we have to read about disaffected teens? Because, there’s something called a CHARACTER ARC in which they BECOME. Please give this book a shot – it’s worth your time. If you enjoyed Beth Revis’ book last year, or any of the other going-away-to-space/new-civilization books pubbed recently, you’ll like this. Persevere!